Not so rosey for Rosie

Asians traditionally don’t speak up about injustices — it’s the “don’t bring attention to yourself,” “don’t complain, it’ll cause trouble” syndrome. But more and more, Asian Americans are different.

So when Rosie O’Donnell mocked the sound of the Chinese language a week ago on “The View,” the Asian American Journalists Association’s New York chapter e-mail list began a spirited conversation, with most members outraged and demanding an apology and some cautioning that O’Donnell hadn’t gone on a racist “rant” like Michael Richards, and that it was a poor attempt at humor.

I wasn’t laughing. Like many Asian Americans, I was familiar with that “ching-chong, ching-chong” sound, from when I was taunted by European-American kids telling me to go back where I came from. That sound makes my gut clench as much as a punch. (Click here for the video on YouTube.)

I wondered why Barbara Walters, the producer and one of the other hosts on the show, hadn’t done anything about this. And, I wondered if O’Donnell would have made the comment if Lisa Ling were still one of the other hosts.

The AAJA’s national office in San Francisco followed up with a note of protest a few days later, as did other organizations such as the Asian American Justice Center, with this Dec. 12 statement.

In the meantime, O’Donnell’s spokesman was quoted in the NY Post, saying, “She’s a comedian in addition to being a talk show co-host. I certainly hope that one day they will be able to grasp her humor.” The Post’s typically demure headline on the item was, “ROSIE TO ASIANS: LOOSEN UP.”

Sigh. It’s Asian Americans’ fault for taking offense. We don’t have a sense of humor. I’ve heard that excuse so often as a cover for unconscious (and conscious) racism, that I could puke.

New York City Councilman John Liu has taken up the cause, and now what had been a low-level buzz within the Asian American community is about to explode into primetime. Expect it to make “Entertainment Tonight” if it hasn’t already.

Sure, this isn’t as heinous of a racial incident as Michael Richards’ blowout against African Americans. But this kind of low-level disrespect — and Asians’ historical tendency to take it without complaint — is why Asians are so invisible in American pop culture.

Even conservative Asian American commentator Michelle Malkin, who’s no friend of mine, has come out swinging at O’Donnell. I have to admit, Malkin’s piece is brilliant. Click and be amazed:

Tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Not so rosey for Rosie

  1. Kimi Nakanishi says:


    It is unfortnuate that Rosey O’Donnell is a comedian and can be so crude. She probably likes this attention. It would be my understanding that when she was going up she was able to poke fun at US. Now, to me she is on the wrong side of the tracks not only to her gender choices but her ability to mouth off unprofessionally and the media to back her. This didn’t happen with the person who mocked the blacks or people who mock blacks. Therefore; in all fairness the same should come about to Rosey O’Donnell. We didn’t like it when you called us those awlful horrific names before and we still don’t. There were reasons for our silence it was not only our culture but out of respect for our parents and to assure them we were being good. No one understands better then us if we fail how the house comes down around us by the discipline which was once revered by all Americans!

    I do believe she needs sensitivity classess. We are not the group to poke fun at.

    Remember it is not if Christian, God’s word that supports your life style choices. He does not support same sex relationships! Don’t lash out at us for being more conservative, and don’t make us like you!

    Sincerely yours,

    Cindy Kimi Nakanishi

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.